Following the Outback Bowl, a number of fans seemed to think that Brady Hoke was not the man for the Michigan football coaching job. There have always been knee-jerk reactionary fans, and there will always be some fans upset with Coach X, regardless of what Coach X has done; however, the sheer number of those disappointed in Hoke after the South Carolina loss was simply baffling.
As a result, Fergodsakes.com searched for some way to objectively measure Coach Hoke’s on field results. Today’s Part Two is comparing Coach Hoke’s Michigan head coaching career to date against the coaches who have won a National Championship in the BCS era, using the on field criteria of:
- Total number of wins through 26 games as Head Coach at the school where National Championship was won,
- Wins against the top rival in first two games
- Bowl wins in first two bowl games
Part One compared Coach Hoke to past head coaches of Michigan football, the winningest program in college football history.
The First 26
Brady Hoke has won 19 of his first 26 games as Head Coach of Michigan. How do Hoke’s 19 wins in 26 games stack up among all coaches who have won at least one national title in the BCS era? Here’s the chart:
Hoke is right in the middle, as six coaches have won more than his 19 out of 26, and six have won less. Former Michigan offensive lineman (senior with Team 96) and Offensive Line Coach (1987-94) Les Miles is at 22 along with Urban Meyer from his Florida days. Interestingly, Nick Saban had 18 wins in his first 26 games at both LSU and Alabama.
The average number of wins for these National Championship coaches in their first 26 games is 20. The median is 19.5, and the mode is 18.
Against Biggest Rival
Hoke is of course 1-1 against the Buckeyes. How have National Championship coaches performed in their first two games against their biggest rival?
Only Phil Fulmer with Tennessee failed to get even one win in his first two games against his rival. Five coaches won twice, and six won once.
The average number of wins for these National Championship coaches in their first two rivalry games is 1.33. The median is 1, and the mode is 1.
Looking ahead to the Michigan-OSU game in 2013, of the 12 national championship coach/school combinations, 9 of the coaches won two of their first three games against their rival. Only Fulmer, Chizik, and Saban with LSU won only one of their first three games against their rival. Hoke will look to join the two-win club come November.
It should be noted that the rivals for certain schools are difficult to determine, and there is disagreement even among their most ardent supporters as to who is the biggest rival. Here are the schools and rivals used for these data:
- Tennessee (rival is Alabama)
- FSU (rival is Florida)
- Oklahoma (rival is Texas)
- Miami (rival is FSU)
- LSU (rival is Auburn)
- USC (rival is UCLA)
- Texas (rival is Oklahoma)
- Florida (rival is FSU)
- Auburn (rival is Alabama)
- Alabama (rival is Auburn)
No Michigan Head Coach has ever gone 2-0 in his first two bowl games.
Only four National Champion coaches in the BCS era have gone 2-0 in their first two bowl games.
The average number of wins for these National Championship coaches in their first two bowl games is 1.25. The median is 1, and the mode is 1.
- Hoke Wins in first 26 games: 19. Average for BCS-era National Championship coaches is 20. Median is 19.5; mode is 18.
- Wins in first two games against OSU: 1. Average for BCS-era National Championship coaches is 1.3. Median is 1; mode is 1.
- Wins in first two bowl games: 1. Average for BCS-era National Championship coaches is 1.25. Median is 1; mode is 1.
Sources: Official school football websites